Alabama may be rocketing toward a confrontation with the U.S. Supreme Court after a state judge seemingly threw the brakes on gay marriage.
Controversial Alabama Chief Justice Roy Moore on Wednesday said state probate judges remain under a court order to refuse marriage licenses to gay couples even though a U.S. Supreme Court decision effectively legalized same-sex marriage more than six months ago.
The outspoken chief justice, who previously tried to block gay marriage from coming to the Deep South state, issued an administrative order saying the Alabama Supreme Court never lifted a March directive to probate judges to refuse licenses to gay couples.
“Until further decision by the Alabama Supreme Court, the existing orders … that Alabama probate judges have a ministerial duty not to issue any marriage license contrary to the Alabama Sanctity of Marriage Amendment or the Alabama Marriage Protection Act remain in full force and effect,” Moore wrote.
The chief justice stopped just short of directly ordering judges to refuse the licenses. He wrote in his order that he was not “at liberty to provide any guidance to Alabama probate judges on the effect of (the Supreme Court ruling) on the existing orders of the Alabama Supreme Court.”
Nonetheless, at least three Alabama counties suspended all marriage license operations — not issuing licenses to anyone— as a result of his order.
The state Supreme Court issued its directive to refuse licenses to gay couples at the request of a conservative group after a federal judge ruled in January 2015 that the state’s gay-marriage ban was illegal. Months later, in June, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a ruling that effectively legalized gay marriage nationwide.
The state court had asked for briefs on how to proceed after the U.S. high court ruling, but never issued any follow-up orders. Moore said he was issuing his latest administrative order on Wednesday because there was “confusion” among probate judges on how to proceed. s.
Susan Watson, director of the ACLU of Alabama, predicted that Moore’s order would have little effect. Watson noted that the same federal judge who initially overturned Alabama’s gay marriage ban also issued an injunction prohibiting probate judges from enforcing the ban.
Most judges in Alabama’s 67 counties are issuing marriage licenses to gay couples, although at least three Alabama counties suspended all marriage license operations Wednesday in response to Moore’s order. That is in addition to the judges in nine counties who had already shut down their operations following the U.S. Supreme Court decision.
One of those who took action Wednesday was Mobile County Probate Judge Don Davis, who said in a statement that he had closed the marriage license office to “ensure full compliance with all court rulings.”
Alabama Rep. Patricia Todd, D-Birmingham, the only openly gay member of the Alabama Legislature, said it is time for Moore to stop fighting the ruling of the U.S. Supreme Court.
“He’ll be challenged and he’ll lose and he’ll cost the state a lot of money in the process,” Todd said.
Moore has become one of the state’s most outspoken opponents of gay marriage, and he has won praise from some conservative groups for his position that states should continue to try to fight the U.S. Supreme Court over the issue. In his order Wednesday, he wrote that it was “yet to be determined” if the state Supreme Court would agree with judges who have suggested that the U.S. Supreme Court decision is up for interpretation.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.
Scot says
The Federal Government needs to keep its nose out of States’ business.
Rosech says
I agree. States have rights and do not have do what this administration is trying to force down everyone’s throat. Someone needs to stand up and this Judge did it. My he not meet a cruel death because of it because, like Hillary, t his administration thinks they are gods and can do anything and no one can stand in their way. Are we prepared? If not, we had better get our acts together and face facts. We are in a fight for our lives and our country NOW!
IsaiahR says
Do you remember an Alabama governor who tried to block a young black woman from entering the University? At least Gov. Wallace changed in later life and was reconciled with that woman. Now we have an Alabama Supreme Court judge telling people they don’t have to obey the law. In both cases the federal government has to intervene to protect people’s civil rights. Maybe such intervention won’t be necessary when bigotry doesn’t guide public policy.
LARRY fRAME says
Your president does not obey the law either, so what’s good for one is good for the other.
LARRY fRAME says
Your president does not obey the law either, so what’s good for one is good for the other.
David says
Federal government needs stay out of states business & stop trying to in force illegal laws they have no constitutional right to make in the beginning
STMA says
I’m still waiting for someone to show me where the US Constitution says the Supreme Court has any authority to make any rulings whatsoever on marriage, much less make their own laws, which this most certainly is. It’s a state issue all the way. Just because our benevolent govt. passes illegal legislation all the time doesn’t make it OK. Sorta like stealing must be OK because they all do it.
Texas Son says
It always depends on what side of the fence you are on… I notice that Obama is ignoring enforcing federal law on marijuana in several states,including Colorado and Washington. He’s letting them experiment. State’s Rights??
Diana says
Look the surpreme court had know right to change, natural law, twist the law to what we all know is wrong it was wrong sense time began and it will always be wrong, and these queers should Never be aloud to raise children, if a guy can screw a guy he can a woman, and if a woman uses a dildo than she can do a man, so they are Perverted, and this should never be aloud here in America, we are not Europe our fore fathers faught and died to have a better, free, caring, honorable, moral life and because some perverts want to distort and twist the truth, we need to stop this know and I with this Judge.
Roland says
Well said
William M.Lahti says
You have failed to make a case on two points here. First the constitution prohibits the federal government from being involved in issues dealing with marriage among many other issues. The constitution provides specific guidelines for what the federal government in responsible for and states that ALL other issues are left up to the states. The supreme court can not decree that anything to do with marriage is a federal issue and thus “make new law”. They are there to interpret the law according to the constitution and they violated that by this decision. Thus the federal so called legalization of marriage is null and void on it’s face. Secondly, it being up to the states to manage issues of marriage then the Alabama state statute is the governing principle to which all are subject to. No marriage licenses that are issued to gay couple are legal in Alabama as a result. It seems as though all you liberals continue to go by the Obama rule of governing. This is, if I don’t like it then I will change it. Except neither Obama or the SC have the authority to change anything to do with marriage in any of the states per the constitution of these United States. I don’t care how much crying, sobbing, whining, bleeding heart stories, or any other BS you try to shovel down our throats. It don’t amount to a hill of beans. You are wrong and the state of Alabama is correct. The federal courts have NO RIGHT to interfere here and are not protecting anybody’s civil rights. That issue of civil rights for gay marriage is not a settled issue. The current laws on the books of the individual states are the governing authority on this issue. If some states want to change their state constitutions to allow such marriages to be legal then that is up to them to go about it in the only legal process allowed. Which is to set a bill in motion to change their constitution and then follow that process as dictated by their state law as to how to make that change happen. Ever since this illegal POS in our WH started to make his own laws and violate our constitution everybody thinks that that is how it is done and that it is ok for this to apply to everything across the board. Well, I’m sorry, it doesn’t work like that. The founders set up our constitution to function the way it does so that we have a balance of power between the three separate branches of the federal government. That was done on purpose to keep an out of control president let’s say in this example from just writing decrees and making new law with out due process. You liberals need to go back and reexamine our education system which no longer teaches government or civics anymore. It seems none of you understand the how and why of how our government works and would continue to work if posers like this one we have now would follow the rules. This is not a dictatorship it is a representative republic where in we the people are the ones that should ultimately be making all major decisions of this type. That is further down the process in case you are unaware of that also. Nothing has been put up for referendum in this country in decades. It is time we reestablish the representative form of government that this country was founded on and functioned for over two hundred on.
Confoundmeonce says
Alabama>>>Stay the course >>Don`t Fold in this So Important Battle to Save Our Country. The Path this “”Kind of legislation” is Leading This Country DOWN…Is The Path of Utter Ruin. A Country is Made up of Its` People. And People Who Follow Gods` Laws are Never going to Be Crushed. One Man and One Woman Makes A Marriage. Nothing else Will ever suffice. Only Chaos and Troubles Will Come of This ‘same sex Marriage Thing. It is Totally unnatural.. And Hurtful. Think Of How Much This Kind of Action Hurts Children…( Born Not Having true Direction ..And No Foundation to Build upon. ) All of you ”Selfish Wanna Have What You DO”..Regardless of How Wrong..IS going to Be your downfall. Read Gods` Word.. And Follow Him ! Then you cannot go Wrong .
Dennis Woodhull, Sr. says
Take your fags and lesbos and stick ’em where the sun don’t shine buddy !!
Colin says
Change, apart from constitutional law is lawlessness. That definition applies not only to the U.S. Constitution governing the affairs of this nation, but the constitutional makeup of the human race. No one is conceived or born of a homosexual union. Therefore, gay marriage is not a civil issue. The term “civil” concerns community life as distinguished from the military, criminal, ecclesiastical, or international proceedings. The community is comprised of biological parents to every human being, and rightfully sustained, those parents are the backbone of the home for the nurture and sustenance of their offspring.
By constitutional makeup, we mean the system of fundamental laws and principles that prescribe the nature, functions, and limits of our physiological being. Male and female are differentiated for very specific functions, and it is only the perversion of these principles that make claim to a “civil right” for personal pleasure. Sure, we challenge the law of gravity, but only short-term, and at very great cost. We depend upon the law of gravity for the orderly operation of all universal bodies. Without these set laws, chaos and destruction would soon follow. And that is precisely what is happening within each society that encourages and accommodates license without restraint. Just ponder the depth of this stated truth, and look at the evidence in societies around the globe that defy the principles of constitutional order.
Wendy Luckie says
Hey, HUMANS didn’t make the sex laws…… GOD did. He also didn’t want you to marry your mama or sister or brother. Prostitution He said no. All the Divine Laws are to keep us alive and well. Ah, heard of Gonorhea, syphilis, HIV? Contracted by nasty sex. Read Leviticus. Oh yes, and Oedipus Rex!
Roland says
I agree
Mary Jones says
Amen!
Frank Bort says
I am proud of Alabama Chief Justice Roy Clark; right on brother!!! We need more heroes like Judge Clark; remember we either hang together or we hang alone.
walter says
READ THIS ALL THE WAY THROUGH AND PLEASE THINK WHAT COULD HAPPEN IN THIS COUNTRY TOMORROW. PLEASE PRAY IT DOES NOT HAPPEN, I AM.
1 ASK YOURSELF HAVE WE BEEN SET UP FOR A MUSLIM INVASION BY OBAMA HILLARY AND KERRY. HOW MANY MUSLIMS ARE IN HIS MANAGEMENT TEAM?
2 WHY ARE THERE A BIG FEMA CAMP IN EVERY STATE, SOME MORE. COULD IT BE TO HOLD MUSLIMS LISTED AS REFUGES? IS IT TO HOUSE RADICAL MUSLIMS? ALSO, I BELIEVE WE HAVE 30 MUSLIMS TRAINING CAMPS ESTABLISHED HERE.
3 KENTUCKY H AS A REPUBLICAN GOVERNER THIS YEAR MAYBE HE WILL TELL US WHAT IS GOING ON ABOUT THE FEMA CAMP IN EAST KY., WITH ARMED GUARDS, I CANNOT FIND OUT.
4 WHERE DID ALL THE AMMO GO THAT THEY BOUGHT UP?
WHY TAKE OUR GUNS?
5 I AM A REGISTERED DEMOCRAT, A CHRISTIAN AND A VETERAN OF THE KOREAN WAR, 52/53, BUT AFTER GATHERING ALL THE FACTS, I VOTE FOR THE MOST QUALIFIED PERSON, NOT A PARTY. DONALD TRUMP IS THAT PERSON.
6 QUESTIONS YOU SHOULD ASK YOURSELF, REGARDLESS IF YOU ARE REPUBLICAN, DEMOCRAT, OR INDEPENDENT. ARE THE THOUSANDS OF MUSLIMS OBAMA IS TRYING TO BRING INTO THIS COUNTRY A START OF AN INVASION OF HIS MUSLIM COMRADS?
7 ALL SENATORS AND REPRESENTATIVES HAD BETTER GET TOGETHER NOW AND BLOCK ALL MUSLIMS FROM ENTERING. CITZENS CONTACT YOUR GOVERNMENT REPRESENTATIVES AND DEMAND THEY TAKE ACTION.
8 WHAT WILL YOU DO WHEN/IF WHOLESALE KILLING STARTS, HOLLER FOR OBAMA. YOU BETTER HAVE A GUN AND PLENTY OF AMMUNITION. IF ONE AMERICAN DIE FROM AN INVASION OF MUSLIMS, THE PEOPLE THAT LET THEM IN SHOULD BE ROUNDED UP AND PROSCUTED FOR ASSITING THE KILLERS.
9 WE HAD BETTER ARM EVER SOLDIER & VET. WE HAVE AND FORCE THEM TO CARRY THEM WITH PLENTY OF AMMUNITION. IF MENTALLLY QUALIFIED. THIS SHOULD BE DONE IMMEDIATELY. WE DO NOT NEED A PERMIT, WE HAVE THE 2 ADMENDMENT. NO JUDGE, GOVERNER OR GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS HAS THE RIGHT TO SAY WE CANNOT. A LAW HAS TO BE PASSED.
10 TRUMP IS THE MOST QUALIFIED PERSON TO RUN THIS COUNTRY HE IS NOT OBLIGATED, HE IS A 2 FISTED, IN YOUR FACE, TAKE NO CRAP FROM ANYONE, INCLUDING THE PRESS.
11 ARE THERE 35 MUSLIM TRANING CAMPS HERE IN THE USA AND ONE 8 MILES OVER IN MEXICO?
12 WHY DID OUR GOVERNMENT TRY AND BUY UP ALL
AMMUNITION WITH OUR TAX MONEY AND ARE TRYING TO TAKE ALL GUNS, IS IT TO HELP AN INVADING ARMY?
WHERE IS THIS AMMUNITION AT TODAY?
13 IS OBAMA BRINGING IN UN TROOPS TO POLICE OUR MAJOR CITIY’S? IF SO, COULD THIS BE PART OF A PLAN TO INVADE THIS COUNTRY?
14 WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IF AN INVASION HAPPENS?
WOULD THERE BE A NEW PRESIDENT? I DO NOT THINK SO.
15 WOULD IT NOT BE BETTER IF EVERY PERSON HAD A
GUN, WITH PLENTY OF AMMUNITION, IF WE WERE
INVADED?
16 WHY IS OBAMA, KERRY AND HILLIARY. BRINGING IN
160 THOUSAND YOUNG MUSLIMS? COULD IT BE FOR
AN IVASION?
17 WHY WAS A SHIPPMENT OF OVER 120 PLANES & OVER
100 TANKS TO EGYPT STOPPED AFTER THE ARMY KICKED
THE RADICAL MULIMS OUT OF CONTROL LAST YEAR?
WAS THE SHIPMENT TO HELP THE RADICALS?
18 WAKE UP AMERICA, YOU HAVE NOT SEEN ANYTHING YET.
19 WHY DID OUR GOVERNMENT GIVE 5 TOP TERRIOST FOR ONE TRAITOR? WAS OBAMA PROTECTING HIS COMRADES.
20 DID YOU BELIEVE OBAMA WHEN HE SAID ON NATION WIDE TV THAT HE WAS A MUSLIM? I BELIEVE THIS IS THE ONLY TRUTH HE HAS SAID.
21 DO YOU BELIEVE OBAMA TO BE BLACK? HIS MOTHER WAS WHITE, HIS DAD A NORTH AFRICA ARAB.
22 DO YOU BELIEVE THAT THIS GOVERNMENT HAS FORCED ISRAEL TO NUKE IRAN? IF SO. I BELIEVE A NORTHEN ARMY WILL COME DOWN AND ATTACK ISRAEL AND GOD, NOT ISRAEL WILL DESTROY 3/4TH OF THAT ARMY IN THE VALLEY THERE.
23 WHY HAS BLACK AMERICA TURNED AGAINST THE
PARTY THAT FREED THE SLAVES. LINCOLN WAS A REPUBLICAN, HE AND THOUSANDS OF WHITES DIED TO FREE THE SLAVES.
24 DO YOU BELIEVE THAT THE DEMOCRATS STARTED THE KKK. I KNOW THEY DID.
25 WHY ARE OUR TROOPS NOT ALLOWED TO HAVE GUNS AND AMMUNITION? COULD IT BE TO KEEP THEM FROM STOPPING AN INVASION?
26 I COULD TAKE 100 ARMED MUSLIMS AND TAKE OVER ANY UNARMED MILITARY BASE, IF YOU WAS PREPAIRED TO KILL EVERY ONE ON THAT BASE AS MUSLIMS DO. IF SO, WHAT COULD YOU DO WITH 260 THOUSAND OR MORE.
27 ANALYZE THESE QUESTIONS AND MAKE UP YOUR MIND ON WHAT WE NEED TO DO TO PROTECT OUR COUNTRY AND PREVENT A UNBELIVABLE BLOOD BATH IF ALL OF THE ANSWERS ABOVE IS YES.
28 MILLIONS ARE TRAINED AND CAN TRAIN OTHER TO USE GUNS, VETS,TROOPS,COPS, HUNTERS WE DON’T NEED PERMITS WE THE SECOND ADMENDMENT AND NO LAW SURPRESS THAT.
29 I SAY, CONTACT YOUR ELECTED OFFICIALS EVERY DAY AND LET THEM KNOW HOW YOU FEEL. ARE YOU FOR AMERICA?
30 I DO NOT KNOW HOW LONG I WILL BE ABLE TO SEND THIS OUT, OUR GOVERNMENT MAY DECIDE TO STOP ME.
31 IF YOU ADD EVERYTHING UP IT REALLY LOOKS LIKE THE PRESENT ADMINSTRATION IS BACKING A MUSLIM TAKE OVER HERE.
32 MAIL THIS TO ALL YOUR FRIENDS, DEMOCRATS, REPUBLICAN OR INDEPENDENTS IF YOUR ANSWERS IS YES. & PRAY IT DOES NOT HAPPEN. I DO.
Wendy Luckie says
You have hit that nail on the head fellow American. That’s all that needs to happen………. CORRUPT GOVT suspending the manufacturing of ammo. Mr. Trump is the ONLY catalyst to make America great again. Both houses of Congress slimy CORRUPT. Extreme court is no different. Can’t even do their job and follow the Constitution. Sad. ????????
Suzy says
I am surprised that you would even use the word Democrat and Christian in the same sentence.
Let’s not forget who is on the throne…..nothing happens that God does not allow, ever think everything that everything happening in the USA today is because of the wicked, vile, sinful nation we have come and most have turned their backs on God – or have moved over to the side of evil and sin as the Israelite’s did so often in the OT, what happened to them?
I am glad I have read the end of the book….keep the faith everyone!
Hugiaino says
Yes, Suzy, but we can make a difference now. How can we do that? We can pray. (No, it’s not a last resort!) When we gripe and moan, we get nowhere! We must fight, not the wrong way, but the right way. (See “War Room.”)
Join Ted Cruz’ Sunday school teacher on Tuesday mornings to pray that God blesses our country exceeding abundantly above all we can ask or think. Sign up at https://www.tedcruz.org/pray/
We can try to fix everything ourselves or we can work with God and let Him do the heavy lifting. After all, He is the only one who can change hearts. He is the only one who can give each of us Ephesians 3:20 days and years!
Elle McCarthy says
God is good, God is great!!!! But like I told a minister that I work with, if we are ever on a sinking ship (and we are now) and all we have is one gun, one life raft and one Bible—— I get the gun and life raft!! If they come and try to take my head off, I’m gonna take a few of them with me. I will NEVER wear a Burka.
Hugiaino says
Oh stop yelling!
walter says
IT IS TIME WE THE PEOPLE ABOLISHED THE SUPREME COURT AND ELECTED ONE JUDGE FROM EACH STATE AND HAVE A TERM LIMIT OF 6 YEARS, ALSO A TERM LIMIT OF 6 YEARS FOR ALL POLITICIANS. IT IS PAST TIME WE ALLOWED PEOPLE TO STAY A LIFE TIME IN OFFICE. THEY WORK THE FIRST HALF LEARNING THE BUSINESS AND THE SECOND HALF TRYING TO GET ELECTED AGAIN. SO, WE GET NO WORK OUT OF THEM AT ALL. THEY SIGN BILLS THEY NEVER READ, OUR GOVERNMENT IS SICK NOW AND MUST BE HEALED AND TRUMP IS THE ONLY ONE THAT CAN HEAL IT. HE IS NOT OBLIGATED TO ANYONE, WILL TAKE NO CRAP FROM ANYONE INCLUDING THE PRESS.
Hugiaino says
Walter, stop yelling!
Confoundmeonce says
Hugiano…Sometimes it is Necessary to YELL ! So..Bear with it, and Understand Why Anyone yells. Maybe They are “Sick and Tired of Being ‘calm’ and never being heard. There does Come a Time When More of US Should Start Screaming our Heads off !
dan says
i agree 100%
keep the CROOKED DC OUT OF OUR STATE BUSINESS
STARTING FROM THE TOP DOWN
anita says
Roy Moore ,thank you for having the Guts to tell them ,if only the rest of the gutless Judges would show some Backbone ,but the gutless wimps do nothing to earn their Salary
daniel says
Amen
Dave Ngbea says
Excellent. Read the Bible. It is very clear on this subject.
KayO says
I started reading some from Obama’s book, The Audacity of Hope, last night. Who knew that he was planning this whole gay marriage thing way back in 2001? Not to mention that he completely misrepresented biblical principles and such. I don’t care for Obama, and reading his ignorant rants only disgusts me so I never put the energy into reading anything that he’s written. Everything that he’s doing was planned well in advance. Only his useful idiots don’t see it.
william says
You people have forgotten your civics’ lessons. There’s no law from congress to make gay marriage legal. The supreme court doesn’t have the power to make law! They interpret law, & write decisions on the existing law. Congress makes the laws. & that woman in Kentucky should !! SUE !! the hell out of that judge for Malicious prosecution. & faults imprisonment.
David says
wrong the US constitution is the law. Life ,Liberty and the pursuit of hapiness. what don’t you understand about that.
William M.Lahti says
Oh grow up already. You didn’t make a single point here in the overall discussion we are having. Nothing about that phrase solves any issues and just goes to show everybody how simplistic your mind works.
walter says
LOOK WHAT MY DEMOCRATIC PARTY DID TO THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WITH OBAMA CARE AND I BLAME BOTH PARTIES, WE DO NOT NEED ANOTHER POLITICIAN FOR PRESIDENT, WE NEED A TOP BUSINESS MAN, DONALD TRUMP.
TAXES THAT HAVE BEEN RAISED WITH OBAMA CARE AND I BLAME THE SENATE AND HOUSE OR REPRESENTATIVES FOR LETTING THIS HAPPEN. LOOK WHAT HAPPENED TO YOU BECAUSE OF WE THE PEOPLE HAVE ALLOWED THIS TO HAPPEN.
MEDICARE————————-1.45% TO 2.35%
TOP INCOME TAX——————-35% TO 77.4%
TOP INCOMPE PAYROLL————–37.4% TO 52.2%
CAPITAL GAIN ——————–15% TO 28%
DIVIDEN TAX———————-15% TO 39%
ESTATE TAX———————–0 TO 55%
PLUS ESTATE TRANSTATCION TAX–OF-3.5%
I BLAME ALL CHURCHES,LODGES AND ALL TAX EXAMPTION ENTIES FOR THE SHAPE THIS COUNTRY IS IN. AFRAID OF LOSING THEIR TAX EXAMPTION.
IT IS TIME WE ALL PULLED TOGETHER AND ELECTED A PERSON TO GET OUR COUNTRY STRAIGHT AND THAT PERSON IS DONALD TRUMP.
OBAMA IS DOING WHAT HE SET OUT TO DO DESTROYING AMERICA.
MOST ALL CHRUCHES WILL NOT BRING UP THE MESS WE ARE IN BECAUSE THE GOVERNMENT WOULD MAKE THEM PAY TAXES.
MASONS, KNIGHTS OF COLUMBUS, EAGELS, MOOSE, ALLTHE SAME.
IT IS PAST TIME THAT WE ALL BANDED TOGHETHER AND FOUGHT FOR WHAT IS RIGHT.
ALL POLITICIANS ARE OBLIGATED TO PEOPLE THAT ARE FUNDING THEM AND MOST POLITICIANS ARE ATTORNEYS NOT BUSINESS PEOPLE. THEY KNOW TO CUT DEALS AND THAT IS ALL.
WE NEED A STRONG BUSINESS PERSON TO RUN THIS COUNTRY, A STRAIGHT TALKING, IN YOUR FACE, TAKE NO BUNK FROM ANYONE, INCLUDING THE PRESS. ONE THAT IS NOT OBLIGATED. DONALD TRUMP IS THAT PERSON.
I AM A CHRISTIAN, A REGISTERED DEMOCRAT, A VETERAN AND 50+ YEAR MASON, FORGET PARTY, TOGETHER WE CAN TAKE OUR COUNTRY BACK.
JIM BARBER says
Mr. Trump will need help in the Senate and House! I think it would be helpful to him if we removed the self serving in both houses and gave him new people to work with.. Kick them all out
drbhelthi says
Since when can the rights of a state, or all states within the Republic, be removed by an interpretaiton by the US Supreme Court?
IsaiahR says
Since the beginning of the Republic. State legislatures may pass laws but our Constitution assigns to the US Supreme Court the responsibility and power to affirm or invalidate such laws.
William M.Lahti says
Wrong, wrong, wrong. Did you skip or sleep through your government or civics classes? The SC can not make any laws. Also, the federal government can not make any laws pertaining to marriage. The constitution states specifically what the federal government is responsible for and the rest is left up to the states to manage. Marriage is not one of those things the federal government is allowed to be involved in per the constitution. Get your facts straight before you try to bs those of us here who know and understand what our government is all about.
Len says
Gods question. The Supreme Court of the United States can only interpret what is in front of them NOT make it so. The states have the right to accept the interpretation or not.
David says
Susan Watson of the Against Christian Liberties Union of Alabama is a Marxist/Socialist member of an organization hell bent on destroying our great state along with sodomite Rep Todd who is pushing her sex-sick sodomite perversion. The Supreme Court has no Constitutional authority to rule on marriage and call it law, These people should be dragged into the street and beaten. It is the only way to stop them. God bless judge Moore and may God forgive us.
William M.Lahti says
You are so very right and spot on. Don’t you wish these retarded liberals, who think that whatever Obama or his minions want to do is legal to do just because they say so, would get their heads examined or at least go back to school and take the civics classes they missed?
Justin W says
I’m not sure if Judge Moore has more to his plan than what is listed in the story. If not, it appears that this is going to do nothing more than cost the taxpayers of Alabama a lot of money in legal fees.
I disagree with the Supreme Court decision. They got it wrong. According to the 10th amendment to the Constitution, states are responsible for all aspects of government not specifically granted to the federal government by the Constitution. Each state sets its own rules regarding marriage. For example, some states allow common law marriages.
I think the Supreme Court decision violates the rights granted to the states by the Constitution. I’m not sure what avenue exists to negate their ruling short of amending the U.S. Constitution, which probably wouldn’t make any difference since Washington has a way of ignoring the governing document anyways.
William M.Lahti says
Crying shame isn’t it? That whatever these posers do they think is legal and all their blind sheeple follow suit just because.
Jim Owen says
Constitution says federal govt does not own land except forts, ports and 100 acres for capitol. States! Take back your property and stand up for your rights! No more marriage licenses for anyone! Marriages are a private vow between a man, woman and our Creator! Man’s failing govt has NOTHING to say or do about it! Kick corrupt govt OUT of marriage agreements!!
Marie hoadley says
ALL OF THIS IS TRUE.THE ONLY WAY WE ARE GOING TO ECCAPE WHAT IS ABOUT TO HAPPEN TO AMERICA IS PUT OUR HOPE IN JESUS CHRIST, AND PRAY FOR AMERICA TO REPENT AND TURN WHOLEHEARTEDLY TO HIM. THE WARNINGS ARE ALL AROUND US LIKE THE DAYS OF NOAH .BUT THE PEOPLE IT did not believe. IT CAN’t happen to us, America trouble is at the door . ARE WE GOING TO WAIT LIKE THE FOOLISH VIRIGANS. DON’t put it off get ready now. Acts2:38 Will tell you what to do. Thank you for reading..God bless America.
Terry says
The nation tried once before to take away the right to say yes or no to personal decisions. Prohibition. This spawned the gangster boot legging era, in Chicago no less. SSM takes away the right of states and individuals to say no to the personal decision to get married, if asked by homosexuals to marry them. This also smacks of the Jim Crow and separate but equal schools in the south. Why are only homosexuals given the right to get married? All non-homosexuals are being discriminated against. The use of “rights” has turned into patronage politics, which the dimocrats are good at since it was the dims that used Jim Crow to give whites various legal patronage hand outs in the south. And the most recent patronage racial assault by the dimocrats has been the confederate flag episode in SC etc. And statues in various places. This smacks of the muslim destruction of the 700 year old statues in Afganistan for religious reasons. There are other things, streets, colleges, and no telling what else that have names related to the Civil War that have not been purged by the democrats under the leadership of BO. And there seems to be separate civil right violation attacks on white police officers when a black is killed by an officer. And despite the fact that all police depts. suspend officers and investigate shootings by any officer. To all police depts. black lives matter since the police do not engage in drive by shootings. And Chinese and Hispanic and all lives matter for all police depts. It seems the real trouble is the Dept of Justice for focusing on matters that are not within their scope. The DOJ should be investigated to see if they are violating the civil rights of citizens. It is also apparent that govt employee lives in Benghazi don’t matter to someone(s)? Another thing the party of blame is good at is always trying to justify what they are doing by blaming others. There are millions of guns owned by millions of people in America and the fraction of people that use guns for illegal and immoral purposes is an insignificant percentage of gun owners. Less then 1 %. The next thing to be tampered with by this admin will be cars. After all cars kill people like guns kill people and they are all registered. They will want to put governors on cars using the standard heavy handed approach this admin is fond of. It seems to me this admin is more dangerous to the peace and tranquility of this nation then guns, cars or flags. Or Christians or jews. Plus nobody has a jihad against us but …….!
john says
Personally I feel, and not from a religious point that people who are gay, bisexual, or lesbian are mixed up. If one believes in reincarnation I would think these people are carrying into this life an influence from a previous one in which they were of the opposite:be it man or woman. Everyone comes into this life to learn from their experiences and obviously they have theirs. I have an adverse feeling to this for me and my lifestyle. However I feel they have a right to be mixed up if they want to be. As long as they harm no other and pay their way and are not a burden to others why not let them be. They have as much right to live their live style as I do mine. I don’t think that same sex marriages should be considered in the same sense as the marriage between a man and woman. That’s ridiculous. It just isn’t. Let’s see if legally we can set up over our whole nation and all our states a legal “union” for these people. One that can be accepted and beneficial for everyone. Let’s forward legal and impersonal respect for all.
J v says
If gay marriage was OK, then why did God destroy Sodom and Gammon a? ?
Jamie Foxx says
Any of the gay community explain why God destroyed Sodom and Gammora?
Nick says
We should follow God’s Laws and not US Supreme Court’s fags rule.
j. clark says
All states should get out of the marriage business, that will leave the churches to do the job. They will not be forced to marry same sex couples. In fact, let the gay community start their own gay churches and do their own marriage business, that lets the rest of the world off the hook for being forced to marry some body they have no interest in.
Nick says
Anyone supporting gay marriage is supporting the destruction of a human race because gay marriages can’t produce children. If all marriages were gay marriages the human race would be extinct in about 120 years. This is a death sentence for a human race and anyone supporting gay marriages has to be insane. Those perverts and their supporters are sinners. They will have to answer for their sins to God at the Hereafter. Wow to them there.
JUNE LEWAN says
“CAN’T WE ALL JUST GET ALONG ?””” REMEMBER THAT ONE ? IT’S STILL TRUE.
f Mitchell says
Hang in there Judge,,,,,,, we are standing up for you.
Jallen says
A person’s sexual orientation, is NOT a civil right. This issue is not about a person’s right to marry who they choose. Where do you draw the line??? …..what about a Father who wants to marry his daughter? A woman in love with her brother?isister…..How can it be unlawful for Men to have multiple wives? These are sexual preferences, or rather, perversions. These are NOT civil rights. This is NOT to be compared with the Civil Rights Movement. This is a moral issue. Each state should be able to govern itself.
DixieBelle says
The governors of states should have the right to issue executive orders effecting their states, if Obama has the right to issue executive orders effecting the government. Governors are responsible for what takes place in their states, and are more aware of what is best for their citizens, and those that voted for them. Obama should keep his nose out of state business instead of thumbing it at everyone.