There’s a big problem with our air travel system – it could cause planes to collide mid-air, and the airlines aren’t doing anything about it. That’s at least according to these five air traffic controllers. The five have exposed a problem that is putting planes at risk of colliding or accidents due to wake turbulence, a federal whistleblower protection office said Tuesday.
The problem occurs when pilots, air traffic control centers or airline dispatchers try to make changes to a flight plan by creating a second plan for the same flight, according to letters sent to the White House and Congress by the Office of Special Counsel, an independent agency.
The “pre-departure clearance” computer software designed to automate the filing and amending of flight plans and the delivery of departure clearances isn’t capable of flagging or identifying multiple plans that have been filed for the same flight, the letters said. This can result in a controller clearing a flight for departure based on an outdated plan, and the pilots flying a route not anticipated or planned for by the controller.
To try to catch the problem, controllers have to go through the time-consuming process of reviewing flight plans, calling pilots and searching through paper strips that are passed among controllers and marked to track a plane’s progress from taxing to takeoff. Then they compare the information on the paper strips to data displayed on computers.
The controllers who revealed the problem work at the Detroit Metropolitan Airport in Romulus, Mich. But the problem affects air traffic nationwide.
“The investigation found that air traffic control facilities across the national airspace system are encountering this problem on a regular basis, and that it is significantly more common during inclement weather periods,” said Special Counsel Carolyn Lerner.
Airlines are more likely to make multiple revisions in flight plans during bad weather. Those also tend to be periods when controllers have a heavier than normal workload.
In 2012, the FAA created a working group to address the problem of multiple flight plans. However, the counsel’s office said FAA officials have acknowledged the group “had little impact.” The agency also told the counsel’s office that senior officials either were not aware of, or did not perceive, the significance of the problem.
Controllers also disclosed other problems with the pre-departure clearance system, including erroneous alerts and notifications, Lerner said in her letters. Sometimes the system displays revision alerts when no changes have been made, a flight doesn’t exist, or it’s already departed, she said.
This is clearly another case of FAULTY computer programming. The mental work of Air Traffic Controllers is adequately stressful, without complications being added by computer programming that interferes, rather than assists.
After several airliners crash together, several hundred airline passengers have been unnecessarily killed, and several billion $$ in claims have been paid out, insurance companies will require “senior personnel” to correct the computer programming problem.
You are right. I am way too afraid to fly. Always have been. Though I have flown to Texas and Alaska. But no more for me. Not because of THIS. Just don’t trust planes and pilots.
But a lot will have to be lost just to get serious about it. And do something about it.